Generally, I no longer think that people being angry matters. If Americans had the bare minimum political memory, Jan 6 would have ended trumpism
Oh I think people's anger matters. There's too much of it over trivial things --the shiny objects-- and not enough channeling of it towards constructive work on defining and resolving our problems.
January 6th matters too. It's huge. It doesn't mean the same thing to the left and the right in the USA. That's not to say all on the left and all on the right have the SAME different interpretations. But generally they do remember it differently, compare it to other historical events differently, cast blame differently, even have different ideas of how much it really matters as time goes by.
This division is a huge problem for the very concept of "USA" down the road, same as the lingering other effects of a Civil War that never yet has faced truth and reconciliation, but in the meantime the split gets to wear all kinds of other clothes instead. A lot of the mini-divisions are really stupid, made up to keep the gap open because gotcha politics is everything in some circles whether on the left, right, independent or indifferent. We need a scorecard to know what the F "free speech" even means anymore -- to whom, and for what purpose.
The things we have in common are still very very basic though, like our need for water, food, protection from the elements, health, safety, literacy, numeracy, a sense of belonging and community.
So fast forward to 2025 and any of Trump's 2024 supporters who now get nicked in the pocketbook by the Trump 2.0 capers are going to be very angry at someone... even if Trump did say "it could be painful" before America somehow becomes "great again".
It will eventually matter that Trump and his grifting cronies catered to the wealthy at the expense of his supporters among the working poor and remains of a middle class. That becomes something akin to the history of say the wealthy family-run former governments of El Salvador and the Domincan Republic. Free speech at that point is usually angry peasants with pitchforks. No wall high enough.
Trump hopes it goes like that. He gets off imagining a cause to declare martial law and throw his own version of Tienanmen Square in Lafayette Park. Not sure he realizes yet that the riotous dissent he faces at that point will be MAGA, not "woke lefties" from the universities.
The problem there is that American MAGA members of 2025 are not Chinese students of 1989. The former have guns by the truckload. If Trump wants their guns he'll have to take them, and he has no clue how his own army will act when facing a choice of following his order to fire on other Americans or.... join them in a coup.
As for the alleged woke lefties and any other Trump 2.0 resisters, it behooves them meanwhile to try really hard starting yesterday for a rearrangement of Congress in the 2026 midterm elections.
A militia-led coup down the road by the right against Trump and cronies would be a nightmare for everyone, even worse then the coup by other names -- DOGE, the broligarchy-- that we're all experiencing today, only because it's possible some on the far right in the exec branch and in congress right now, and some in the military, would also openly support it.
Trump is a token of their intentions. The far right don't need him once things get bad enough. They're ready to run a real dictatorship, not this reality TV pilot starring Elon and Felon. They actually count on the anger from the populist right (not the left) to fuel their coup. Trump feeds it by talking constantly about "American carnage" and how dark it is... when the country's economy is in pretty good shape. He is at once a feared head of state because of his petty vindictiveness, and a trapped pawn of the anger he has stirred up among his own supporters for a decade.
So I think anger matters. I think checking it matters! It matters to call out the political manipulation of our emotions, and to hold Congress accountable to their oaths and their duties of representing us responsibly.
Forget the tax cuts for corporations and wealthy individuals -- gimme a break, the taxes on those guys were far higher in the 1960s and the dudes still had time to play golf midweek and money to buy their daughters a house as a wedding gift. Forget the stupid tariff wars and wholesale ditching of regulations.
None of that over-the-top "change" is what ordinary Americans actually voted for, not even MAGA voters. They want change but not this grifter-run vandalizing of a constitutional government with agencies that have served us pretty well for hundreds of years.. else we would not still BE the superpower we are. We run a terrible risk letting an irrationally angry man like Trump abuse that power. There's truth in the idea of fighting fire not with fire but water. Time to chill him out in court, not on the street and definitely not on social media.